Hard hits, fighting, physical toughness; these are the
things that ice hockey is known for. Fans all over America and Canada turn on
the NHL network to watch their favorite players throw big hits. There is no
doubt that this aspect of the game adds excitement and marketability. For
example, fans have coined terms such as “kronwalled” to describe the force with
which Niklas Kronwall is able to hit. However, despite the excitement that
stems from such physicality, it is high time to consider how these hits effect
the health of hockey players, not only at the professional level but also in
youth hockey.
After an increase of
knowledge about the effects and causes of concussions, the NHL has attempted to
decrease the frequency of such injuries. Through rule 48 they have banned all
hits to the head in the hopes that this would reduce the prevalence of concussions
within the league. However, concussions continued to increase even after the
new rule was put in to effect. This has caused a debate within the hockey
community as to what is the best way to go about protecting its players.
Youth hockey players have looked up to those in the NHL
since the first time they laced up their skates. This means that when they see
a big hit on television, they become eager to play with this high level of
physicality in their own games. As a result, concussions in youth hockey have
become an issue that needs addressing. Youth hockey associations such as Hockey
Canada and USA Hockey have been working towards a safer game in order to
encourage parents to sign their children up for the sport. However, it is not
clear what the best path is for decreasing concussions in youth hockey.
Youth hockey in Canada has banned checking in the peewee age
group (12 and under) in an attempt to hold off on dangerous hits. However, this
only means that children at this age do not learn how to properly body check or
how to properly receive a hit. As a result, when the children are able to check
at the bantam age group (14 and under), they are not doing so in a safe manner.
This leads to even more concussions because learning the proper techniques at
14 means the stakes are higher, that is the hits are harder because the
children are stronger and bigger. In contrast, learning the proper method at
the age of 12 is much safer because hits are not as hard or dangerous, as the
participants are smaller.
Although it is important that Canada is looking in to the
problem of concussions in youth hockey, I believe that their methods are not
the most effective route. Instead, some of the ideas that USA Hockey has
implemented make more sense. One thing that USA Hockey is trying to do is
improve the quality of equipment. Hockey equipment companies such as Bauer, CCM
and Cascade have invested large amounts of money in to creating better helmets
that are more suited to protect against concussions. Additionally, USA Hockey
has began a widespread campaign to educate their coaches about the severity and
dangers of concussions as well as the warning signs that they need to look for
should they think that their player may have sustained a head injury. This
means that fewer concussions are going unnoticed by coaches and that players
are receiving the care that they require after a concussion, such as suspending
participation in physical activities for a time period and consulting with a
physician.
Hard hits will continue to play an integral role in the
sport of hockey, as it has for many years. However, it is important to consider
the safety of hockey players and take measures to best protect them. The NHL
has begun to take measures to decrease concussions and youth hockey followed
suit with strong campaigns from both Canadian and US youth hockey
organizations. There are many ideas that have been proposed in order to
decrease concussions in hockey and many great ideas have already been
implemented. However, the problem is still prevalent and so it is important to
further ask ourselves how we can best protect the youth within the hockey community
from concussions.
Sources:
http://www.latimes.com/news/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-hockey-concussions-20130717,0,6800845.story#axzz2qZqwKlLY
http://www.hockeycanada.ca/en-ca/Hockey-Programs/Safety/Concussions/Facts-and-Prevention.aspx
http://www.usahockey.com/news_article/show/275908?referrer_id=908034
http://www.rocketfishtank.com/blog/bid/254994/Study-shows-underreporting-of-concussions-in-action-sports